Barnwell’s NFL Quarter-Season Awards Highlight MVP and Rookie of the Year Contenders
At 23.5%, It’s Time for a Quarter-Season NFL Review: Who’s Impressing?
Early Standouts in the 2025 NFL Season
The 2025 NFL season is already at its quarter mark, and while we’re still seeing teams and players finding their footing, several names have emerged as potential award winners. With most players having crossed 150 snaps, we can begin identifying those excelling in their respective positions. This review focuses on preliminary picks for various awards, rather than final predictions, based solely on performances observed so far.
Defensive Rookie of the Year: Key Contenders
In a surprising twist, no defensive rookies have stood out with traditional metrics like sacks. Nevertheless, cornerbacks like Will Johnson (Cardinals), Jacob Parrish (Buccaneers), and Billy Bowman Jr. (Falcons) have shown flashes early on. Notably, the Eagles’ Mukuba, a second-round safety, has integrated seamlessly into a strong defensive lineup, making impactful plays like his half-sack on Patrick Mahomes.
Similarly, the 49ers’ slot corner, Stout, has effectively held his ground against bigger offensive players, allowing just an 80.3 passer rating against him. His contributions are becoming crucial for San Francisco’s enforced defense.
Offensive Rookie of the Year: A Wide Receiver Showdown
While rookies in the running back position have amassed significant yardage, three wide receivers have stolen the spotlight. Emeka Egbuka of the Buccaneers leads rookies in receiving yards and touchdowns, showing poise in clutch moments. Meanwhile, Warren of the Colts doubles as a versatile offensive weapon, proficient both as a runner and a receiver.
Protector of the Year: Recognizing Offensive Line Excellence
The new Protector of the Year award celebrates the unsung heroes of the NFL—offensive linemen. Denver’s Garett Bolles and Buffalo’s Dion Dawkins stand out for their robust pass protection, allowing minimal pressures on their quarterbacks.
Coach of the Year Candidates Emerging Strong
Los Angeles Rams’ Sean McVay showcases offensive dominance, exemplified by utilizing 12 personnel groupings effectively. Shane Steichen has crafted a dynamic offense for Indianapolis, harnessing the skills of players like Daniel Jones and Jonathan Taylor to stunning effect.
Defensive Player of the Year: Dominant Forces Unleashed
This category remains fiercely competitive. Myles Garrett of the Browns is unmatched in his combination of power and speed, consistently disrupting offensive lines. Jonathan Simmons continues to dominate, despite battling for success in a struggling Titans team.
Offensive Player of the Year: Non-Quarterback Heroes
With quarterbacks excluded, Jonathan Taylor’s rushing ability places him prominently in this category. On the receiving front, both Smith-Njigba and Puka Nacua shine, with the latter leading in receiving yards and commanding remarkable target rates.
Most Valuable Player: The Best of the Best
While non-quarterbacks like Puka Nacua approach MVP form, three quarterbacks define the season’s narrative. Baltimore’s Lamar Jackson leads in several passing metrics, even as sacks have slightly hindered his performance. Meanwhile, Indianapolis’ Daniel Jones efficiently commands the Colts’ offensive schemes, propelling their strong start.
Ultimately, Buffalo’s Josh Allen stands tall, sustaining high performance across metrics while driving last-minute victories. With consistent plays and minimal errors, Allen retains his crown in 2025, demonstrating unparalleled low-risk, high-reward gameplay.
