Guinness Family Divided by Controversial ‘House of Guinness’ Documentary
House of Guinness: Netflix’s Bold Interpretation of a Brewing Dynasty’s History
The Creation and Controversy Behind “House of Guinness”
“House of Guinness,” Netflix’s newest historical drama series, delves into the lives and legacy of the Guinness brewing dynasty during the late 1800s. Created by Steven Knight, this series takes creative liberties to captivate viewers, weaving in elements of drama and intrigue that may not align perfectly with historical facts.
Steven Knight’s Creative Approach
Steven Knight, known for his work on “Peaky Blinders,” has infused the show with fabricated storylines to enhance the narrative of the Guinness family. He explained in an interview how he leveraged historical events and family traits, supplementing them with fictional elements to complete their stories. This approach helps bridge gaps where historical records fall short.
Historical Fiction and Cinematic License
Audiences are familiar with the bending of truths in historical fiction. Movies and series often add imaginary elements for dramatic effect, and “House of Guinness” is no exception. Knight’s experience with crafting stories for “Peaky Blinders” informed his use of historical texts and conversations with current Guinness descendants to enrich the series’ storyline.
Family Reactions and Criticisms
Not all members of the Guinness family are pleased with the fictional portrayal. Molly Guinness, a great-great-granddaughter of Edward Guinness, criticized the show for using modern clichés about wealthy individuals. She expressed her displeasure over the inclusion of storylines such as Arthur’s fictionalized gay exploits and the creation of Sean Rafferty, a character portrayed by James Norton.
Inspiration from Family and Memoirs
Interestingly, the idea for “House of Guinness” originated within the family. Ivana Lowell, a member of the Guinness family, partly inspired the series through her memoir, “Why Not Say What Happened?” Supposedly triggered while watching “Downton Abbey,” Lowell’s insight into her family’s dynamic and eccentric history spurred the concept for the show.
Future Seasons and Viewer Reception
Despite initial family discontent, the series has garnered a positive response from viewers. Following the premiere season, Steven Knight secured a deal for two additional seasons of a “Peaky Blinders” sequel, indicating his continued interest in the historical setting of 1800s Dublin. Knight is committed to expanding “House of Guinness” through multiple seasons, potentially extending into the 1960s.
Conclusion
While “House of Guinness” might not align entirely with historical records or please every member of the Guinness family, its captivating storytelling has struck a chord with audiences. As the series progresses, viewers can anticipate more dramatic interpretations and expansions of the Guinness legacy.
