Discover Why Kirk Herbstreit and Florida State Fans are Clashing Over the 2023 Playoff Snub

Florida State vs. Miami: A Rivalry Intensified by Commentary

FSU Prepares for Miami Showdown Amidst Tensions with Kirk Herbstreit

As the Florida State Seminoles brace for their highly anticipated match against the Miami Hurricanes, the game will feature commentary from ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit, stirring mixed emotions among FSU fans. The rivalry is set to unfold at Doak Campbell Stadium in Tallahassee at 7:30 p.m. ET on Saturday, October 4, drawing attention not just for the on-field action but also for the off-field tensions linked to past commentary.

Past Grudges: The 2023 Playoff Snub

The origin of the discontent dates back to 2023 when Herbstreit became a controversial figure among FSU supporters. Despite not being part of the College Football Playoff committee, Herbstreit opined that a one-loss Alabama team deserved a playoff spot over an undefeated Florida State, following the injury of FSU’s starting quarterback, Jordan Travis. This stance did not sit well with the Seminoles’ fan base, especially when FSU ended the season as ACC Champions.

Herbstreit’s Return to Tallahassee

Herbstreit’s upcoming appearance marks his first in Tallahassee since 2014. While ESPN’s “College GameDay” will skip the location, top broadcasters, including Herbstreit, Chris Fowler, and Holly Rowe, will be present, highlighting the game’s significance. The match takes place amid FSU fans’ lingering resentment over Herbstreit’s previous dismissals of their team’s playoff qualifications.

Main Points of Contention

• Herbstreit’s assertion that without Jordan Travis, FSU lacked a strong substitute against Alabama.
• Kirk’s comments that even FSU’s wins, like their ACC championship victory with freshman quarterback Brock Glenn, were not enough to surpass Alabama’s merits.
• The Seminoles’ fans’ grievances were vocalized internationally during the 2024 Aer Lingus Classic in Dublin, illustrating the enduring impact of the controversy.

Herbstreit’s Apology: A Step Toward Reconciliation?

In a bid to mend ties, Herbstreit extended an apology to FSU fans during the 2024 CFP selection show, acknowledging the heated disagreement yet affirming his intent to remain respectful and professional in his analyses. This gesture, although appreciated by some, leaves the question open whether Florida State fans are ready to forgive when Herbstreit steps back into Tallahassee.

As FSU faces off against Miami, the clash is not just about the scoreboard, but also the simmering sentiments between a vocal fanbase and a seasoned commentator.