Repeated Domestic Violence Calls Precede Shocking Decapitation at Staten Island Horror House Sources Reveal
New York Tragedy: Staten Island’s Troubled Home and the Final Violence
History of Domestic Disturbance Calls
A Staten Island residence has become infamous for recurring domestic violence incidents, culminating in a tragic crime involving 19-year-old Damien Hurstel. Inside this troubled West Brighton home, authorities reportedly responded to multiple calls since 2021, a history that ended in violence when Hurstel allegedly decapitated his mother’s boyfriend, Anthony Casalaspro, a 45-year-old city Department of Sanitation worker.
Alleged Perpetrator with Troubled Past
Sources revealed Casalaspro was a central figure in at least five 911 calls related to domestic disturbances from the home. Neighbors shared distressing stories, painting a picture of a household plagued by chaos and fear. Just weeks before his death in 2023, Casalaspro allegedly attacked Hurstel and the teen’s mother while under the influence of alcohol.
Community Observations and Recurrent Violence
Residents of Cary Avenue shared troubling accounts of past incidents, shedding light on an environment of ongoing turmoil. One neighbor recounted a particularly harrowing event where Hurstel’s mother suffered a broken leg and dismissed offers to call for emergency help. Such stories reflect a pattern of violence spilling beyond closed doors.
Casalaspro’s Criminal Record
Casalaspro’s history with law enforcement extended beyond domestic violence. Records indicate arrests dating back to 2000, including drug-related charges and more recent offenses, such as possession of a weapon and assaults. These incidents, along with his battle with severe vision loss, depict a life of challenges and conflict.
Mental Health Concerns in the Hurstel Household
Additionally, the Hurstel family was no stranger to mental health crises. The police were alerted to suicide threats made by Hurstel, who reportedly self-harmed in past incidents. Despite these repeated calls for help, the cycle of violence continued unabated, ultimately reaching a tragic and fatal conclusion.
| Year | Incident |
|---|---|
| 2021 | Initial domestic violence call, no weapon found |
| 2022 | Mental health call citing suicide threats |
| 2023 | Final violent incident resulting in Casalaspro’s death |
The dark history of this Staten Island home raises serious questions about intervention and support systems for families in crisis. While the Hurstel family has declined further comment, the community remains shaken by the stark reality of domestic violence in their midst.
