George R.R. Martin and Joe Hill Share Their Top Live-Action Batman Picks and It’s Not Christian Bale for One

At New York Comic Con 2025, renowned authors George R.R. Martin and Joe Hill engaged in a lively discussion about Batman. Their spotlight panel drew attention as they shared their distinct views on the iconic character.

Batman Through the Ages

George R.R. Martin expressed his appreciation for Batman’s darker origins. He lamented that by the 1950s, the character’s complexity seemed diminished. “The original Batman was full of darkness,” Martin stated. He criticized the lighter portrayal from the 50s, noting its silliness.

“The 50s version of Batman is really sort of silly,” he remarked, referencing bizarre scenarios where Batman fought villains in whimsical settings, such as a giant typewriter. Martin acknowledged that Batman regained his darker appeal later, but the interim period featured a distinctly less formidable version.

Defending a Classic

Joe Hill offered a different perspective, expressing his affection for the classic Batman television series featuring Adam West. “I love the TV show!” Hill exclaimed, much to Martin’s surprise. The humor and lightheartedness of the series appealed to Hill, who mentioned memorable moments, like Batman surfing alongside the Joker.

“Some people are like ‘Christian Bale is my Batman,’ Adam West is my Batman,” Hill added, igniting cheers from the audience. Martin’s reaction was one of astonishment as he processed Hill’s contrasting viewpoint.

New York Comic Con 2025 Highlights

New York Comic Con serves as a vibrant hub for fans of pop culture, providing a safe space for self-expression. This year’s event emphasizes inclusivity, welcoming attendees from all backgrounds and identities. It offers an opportunity to celebrate creativity, meet like-minded individuals, and immerse oneself in the diverse world of comics and entertainment.

• Date: 2025
• Event Type: New York Comic Con
• Key Participants: George R.R. Martin, Joe Hill
• Themes: Batman’s evolution, Classic TV series, Pop culture celebration

As the discussions unfolded, it became clear that Batman remains a subject of passionate debate, showcasing the character’s lasting impact across generations.