Philadelphia Medical Examiner Reaffirms Ellen Greenberg’s Death as Suicide According to New Document
In a controversial decision, the Philadelphia Medical Examiner has reaffirmed that Ellen Greenberg’s death is classified as a suicide. This conclusion comes nearly 12 years after her tragic death in January 2011, which had initially been ruled a homicide before a subsequent reclassification.
Ellen Greenberg’s Case Overview
Ellen Greenberg was a school teacher found dead in her apartment in Manayunk with over 20 stab wounds. Her fiancé discovered her body during snowy conditions, leading to an initial ruling of homicide. However, the medical examiner later changed this to a suicide ruling.
Recent Developments
This latest affirmation by the Medical Examiner, Dr. Lindsay Simon, follows a settlement agreement earlier this year that allowed for a reexamination of the case. The family of Ellen Greenberg, represented by attorney Joseph Podraza Jr., has criticized the findings, calling them flawed and biased.
Key Points of Contentions
- Podraza accused Dr. Simon of manipulating evidence to support a predetermined conclusion.
- The family argues that evidence contradicting suicide was overlooked. This includes:
- 3D photogrammetry recreations suggesting self-inflicted wounds were impossible.
- Unexplained bruises and missing surveillance footage.
- Claims of a toxic relationship leading up to her death.
- The attorney also highlighted that over 40 million Americans suffer from managed anxiety, attempting to counteract the portrayal of Ellen’s mental health.
Ongoing Legal Proceedings
Last month, a judge in Philadelphia criticized city attorneys for allegedly not adhering to the settlement agreement. This raised concerns about the city’s commitment to the investigation. The Greenbergs intended to attend a hearing to discuss the medical examiner’s independent review, though the status of this hearing remains uncertain.
Family’s Quest for Justice
Joshua and Sandra Greenberg have long believed their daughter was murdered. They have engaged external experts to challenge what they describe as inadequacies in the police investigation. Despite the city’s ruling, the family remains determined to pursue the truth regarding Ellen’s death.
The ongoing saga highlights the complex nature of this case, illustrating how deeply personal tragedies can intersect with systemic challenges in law enforcement and medical assessments. The Greenbergs continue to seek justice for their daughter in the face of dismissive findings from city authorities.
