Breaking Down the Star Player’s Trade Standoff: Why It’s a Tough Reality and What’s on the Horizon
As St Kilda navigates the complexities of the AFL off-season, a significant focus remains on Rowan Marshall’s future with the team. The Saints are determined to retain Marshall, even as the arrival of free agent Tom De Koning could change his position on the field.
Marshall’s Contract Status and Speculation
Rowan Marshall is contracted with St Kilda until the end of 2027. Nonetheless, discussions surrounding his potential trade intensified throughout 2025, following the recruitment of De Koning. While Geelong expressed interest in acquiring Marshall, St Kilda has firmly shut down these trade talks.
Insights from Industry Experts
Herald Sun journalist Scott Gullan shared insights on Fox Footy’s Trading Day, noting that St Kilda’s stance is clear: Marshall is not on the move. However, Geelong’s General Manager, Andrew Mackie, indicated that discussions regarding Marshall’s acquisition remain open, particularly referencing the possible inclusion of pick 19 in trade negotiations.
- Games Played: 156 matches over nine seasons
- AFL Teams Involved: St Kilda, Geelong
- Contract End Date: 2027
Geelong’s Need for Ruck Talent
The Cats have been scrutinizing their ruck situation. With veterans Rhys Stanley and Mark Blicavs nearing retirement, the need for a seasoned ruckman is evident. Leigh Montagna, a St Kilda legend, acknowledged that bringing in additional talent is crucial for players like Marshall who aim for success.
“Rowan has been well-compensated throughout his career, and with his 30th birthday approaching, time may be running out,” Montagna explained. He emphasized that Marshall’s ability to play as both a ruckman and a forward adds to his value.
Financial Considerations
Concerns about salary disparities also arise within the team. Hawthorn player Ben Dixon highlighted that the potential financial differences between Marshall and other players could create tension in the locker room.
St Kilda’s Off-Season Activity
St Kilda has made notable moves in the trade market this off-season, acquiring four players in just one week. The team has welcomed:
- Tom De Koning (Carlton)
- Jack Silvagni (Carlton)
- Sam Flanders (Gold Coast)
- Liam Ryan (West Coast)
Amid these additions, St Kilda is also facing roster adjustments. Several players have not secured contracts for 2026, while others, including Zaine Cordy and Jimmy Webster, have departed the club.
The Road Ahead for Marshall and St Kilda
The ongoing trade standoff presents a challenging situation for both Marshall and the Saints. As the team looks to build a competitive roster for 2026, the club must manage its player dynamics carefully. With De Koning’s arrival potentially altering Marshall’s role, how St Kilda navigates this transition will be crucial for their future success.
