Paul Murphy TD Files Lawsuit Against Heather Humphreys Over RTÉ Debate Comments
Paul Murphy, a TD representing People Before Profit-Solidarity, has initiated legal action against Heather Humphreys. This lawsuit stems from comments made during an RTÉ radio debate on October 12. Mr. Murphy’s suit, filed with Prospect Law, alleges that Ms. Humphreys made “grossly defamatory” remarks regarding his past involvement in a protest over a decade ago.
Background of the Legal Dispute
The comments in question relate to an incident from November 15, 2014, when Mr. Murphy was charged with false imprisonment during a protest aimed at then-Labour Party leader Joan Burton. Alongside five others, he was acquitted of these charges in 2017. Mr. Murphy’s legal team contends that Ms. Humphreys’ remarks suggested he engaged in violent criminal activities and acted in a misogynistic manner.
Demands from the Legal Letter
- Withdrawal of the comments
- Undertaking not to repeat the statements
- Apology from Ms. Humphreys
- Reimbursement of legal costs
- Suitable compensation for damages
The legal letter sent on October 13 requested a formal response by a specific deadline. Ms. Humphreys acknowledged the lawsuit and stated that while Mr. Murphy was acquitted, he was not simply a passive observer on the day of the protest.
High Court Proceedings
Legal documents have been lodged with the High Court as of Wednesday. To date, no actions have been taken against RTÉ regarding the broadcasted comments. Both Murphy and Humphreys are expected to address inquiries about the matter.
Current Election Landscape
This legal controversy unfolds against the backdrop of ongoing presidential election campaigning. Recent polling data shows Independent candidate Catherine Connolly leading with 38% support. Following her are: Ms. Humphreys from Fine Gael with 20%, and Fianna Fáil’s Jim Gavin, who has withdrawn from the race but still appears on ballots, receiving 5% support.
| Candidate | Support (%) |
|---|---|
| Catherine Connolly | 38 |
| Heather Humphreys | 20 |
| Jim Gavin | 5 |
The survey included 1,200 in-home interviews with adults conducted between October 12-14, yielding a margin of error of ±2.8%. Excluding undecided voters, Connolly’s support rises to 60%, and Humphreys’ to 32%.
Candidates’ Campaign Initiatives
As part of her campaign, Catherine Connolly plans to set up a presidential initiative focusing on the needs of disabled citizens. This would include public discussions and an award scheme to acknowledge contributions in this area.
Heather Humphreys is also outlining her vision, proposing that the Defence Forces should deliver national flags to schools, emphasizing the importance of inclusion and unity in Irish society.
