Blue Jays Face Dilemma as Bo Bichette’s Massive Contract Projection Looms

The Toronto Blue Jays are currently on the verge of the World Series, needing just three wins to reach the Fall Classic. However, the team faces a significant decision regarding star shortstop Bo Bichette. Bichette is poised to enter free agency at the conclusion of this season, following a remarkable offensive performance. Meanwhile, teammate Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has already secured his future with an extension, putting more focus on Bichette’s situation.
Bo Bichette’s Contract Situation
Bichette’s current contract spans three years and is worth $33 million, ranking him 16th among shortstops in terms of average annual value. At just 27 years old, he has achieved notable milestones, including:
- Leading the American League in hits twice
- Being named a two-time All-Star
- Posting a strong batting line of .311/.357/.483 for the current season
Projected Contract Value
Given his performance, there are growing expectations for Bichette’s next contract. A recent projection from Bleacher Report’s Joel Reuter estimates a seven-year deal worth $180 million. This contract could place him as the ninth-highest-paid shortstop in Major League Baseball.
Comparative Deals
For context, Willy Adames signed a similar seven-year deal worth $182 million last offseason. However, Adames’ defensive capabilities at shortstop are unquestioned, contrasting with some concerns surrounding Bichette’s future in that position.
Defensive Considerations
The Blue Jays opted not to extend Bichette last offseason, hinting at internal doubts about his long-term viability as a shortstop. His recent offensive success has bolstered his bargaining position but raises other concerns. If the team decides to transition him away from shortstop due to defensive weaknesses, they may hesitate to pay him at the shortstop level.
Impact on Team Strategy
Currently, if the Blue Jays meet the $180 million projection and move him to third base, Bichette would become the sixth-highest-paid third baseman in baseball. This potential shift reflects the team’s broader strategy as they contemplate their future without him on the field.
As the Blue Jays aim for the World Series, the looming decision regarding Bo Bichette’s value and position could define both his career and the team’s trajectory moving forward.