Randy Johnson Highlights Critical Flaw in Cal Raleigh’s Game as Blue Jays Strengthen Hold on ALCS Title
Randy Johnson, a distinguished former pitcher, has raised concerns regarding the defensive mechanics of Cal Raleigh, the Seattle Mariners’ catcher. His remarks come amid the Blue Jays’ pursuit of the American League Championship Series (ALCS) title, which has sparked renewed interest in Raleigh’s one-knee catching stance.
Randy Johnson Questions Cal Raleigh’s Catching Technique
Johnson has highlighted a critical flaw that many baseball analysts seem to overlook. He remarked, “Announcers won’t say anything about the one-knee catching, will they? How’s it working out for Seattle?” This statement signifies a growing skepticism about the efficiency of the one-knee stance, which is increasingly common in Major League Baseball.
Statistics on Catching Techniques
According to a July 2025 analysis by MLB.com, catchers employing the one-knee stance have recorded improved fielding value compared to those using the traditional two-knee stance. Nevertheless, a deeper examination reveals a complex narrative. Currently, 96 percent of all pitches in the majors are received using the one-knee method, making its statistical advantage somewhat misleading.
Cal Raleigh’s Offensive Performance
Despite questions surrounding his defensive strategies, Raleigh has had an impressive season offensively. The 27-year-old catcher hit 60 home runs and drove in 125 runs, solidifying his place among the top offensive players in the league. His .247 batting average and .359 on-base percentage demonstrate his value to Seattle, particularly with his ability to deliver critical hits.
Blue Jays Strengthen Their ALCS Position
The Blue Jays have fortified their hold on the ALCS after Max Scherzer’s stellar performance in Game 4, levelizing the series at two games each. Toronto is preparing for a pivotal Game 5, featuring a pitching matchup between Kevin Gausman and Bryce Miller. As the series progresses, the focus will shift from theoretical discussions to execution on the field.
Impact of Bo Bichette’s Potential Return
Aside from the tactical discussions surrounding Raleigh’s catching, the Blue Jays are also managing an interesting storyline involving shortstop Bo Bichette. His recovery timeline is critical; should Toronto advance, Bichette’s return could enhance their offensive lineup significantly.
Bichette’s Injury and Recovery
- Bichette suffered a left knee injury on September 6 against the Yankees.
- Before his injury, he was competing for the American League hits title, with 181 hits in just 139 games.
- Bichette boasts a .311 batting average and was just three hits short of the league leader.
Keegan Matheson from MLB.com highlighted that Bichette’s recovery is ongoing, with steady progress in running drills. However, he awaits full medical clearance before returning. If the Blue Jays conquer the Mariners, Bichette’s left knee injury could prove to be the pivotal factor for their postseason success.
