Staten Island Teen Makes First Court Appearance in Shocking Decapitation Case

Damien Hurstel, a 19-year-old from Staten Island, faced the court on October 17, 2025, charged with a shocking crime. Accused of decapitating Anthony Casalaspro, his mother’s boyfriend, Hurstel pleaded not guilty. The incident took place in their West Brighton home, drawing significant attention due to its grisly nature.

First Court Appearance for Teen

During his arraignment in Richmond County, Hurstel showed little emotion. Wearing an orange jumpsuit and appearing gaunt, he spoke only once to affirm his plea. The hearing was presided over by Judge Raymond Rodriguez. Hurstel’s family members were present, observing quietly from the gallery.

Details of the Alleged Crime

The crime occurred on October 6, 2025. Hurstel allegedly stabbed and decapitated Casalaspro, a sanitation worker. Law enforcement sources revealed that Hurstel intended to mutilate the body further using a blender. His actions were witnessed by his 16-year-old sister, who later reported the incident to their mother, Alicia Zayas.

Mother’s Reaction

Zayas expressed disbelief and sorrow over the incident. She recounted her daughter’s chilling phone call, describing the scene and stating, “Damien killed Anthony, and he doesn’t have a head.”

Court Proceedings and Mental Health Concerns

In court, Hurstel appeared detached from the severity of the charges. He was ordered to remain in custody, with mandated psychiatric evaluations and suicide watch due to mental health concerns. His next court appearance is set for November 20.

Community and Family Impact

The horrific nature of the crime has left a lasting impact on the Staten Island community and the families involved. Zayas chose not to comment further following the hearing, highlighting the deep distress that surrounds this case.

The court will continue to address the complexities of Hurstel’s mental health as legal proceedings move forward.