Latest Tuesday Update on Tony Vitello Tennessee Baseball and the San Francisco Giants

Tony Vitello, the head coach of the University of Tennessee baseball team, remains a key figure in ongoing negotiations for the manager position with the San Francisco Giants. As of October 21, 2023, no formal agreement has been finalized.
Current Status of Tony Vitello and the Giants
Vitello was present at Tennessee’s Lindsey Nelson Stadium for a practice and scrimmage on October 21. Despite speculation about his potential move to Major League Baseball, he emphasized to reporters that “nothing is done.” He continued his responsibilities with Tennessee on October 19 by participating in batting practice and was actively involved in team activities.
On October 20, he attended a charity golf outing in support of the Pat Summitt Foundation. Later that evening, he watched the American League Championship Series Game 7, where the Toronto Blue Jays secured a victory over the Seattle Mariners, advancing to the World Series. Notably, Vitello has a close personal relationship with Blue Jays pitcher Max Scherzer, whom he coached during his tenure at the University of Missouri.
Potential Management Move
In a recent team meeting, Vitello addressed questions about his future. He assured his players that they would hear from him directly regarding any career changes. However, sources cite that negotiations between Vitello and the Giants are advancing, possibly leading to his historic appointment as the first college baseball coach to transition directly to an MLB managerial role without prior professional experience.
Giants’ Management Situation
If hired, Vitello would succeed Bob Melvin, who was relieved of his position on September 29, following two underwhelming seasons where the team recorded a 161-163 overall record. Vitello’s current contract with Tennessee is valued at $3 million annually, reflecting his success at the collegiate level.
- Current Tennessee record: 341–131
- First national title in 2024, winning the College World Series
- Two SEC regular-season titles and two SEC Tournament titles
- Impressive performance in 2022 with 57 wins
Should Vitello depart, Tennessee athletics director Danny White might consider promoting either associate head coach Josh Elander or pitching coach Frank Anderson, both of whom have been integral to the program since 2017. Alternatively, a formal coaching search could be initiated, although the timing may pose challenges due to the traditional college coaching cycle.
Vitello’s Impact on Tennessee Baseball
Tony Vitello’s leadership has revitalized the Tennessee baseball program since his hire in June 2017. He guided the team to the NCAA Tournament in 2019 and made significant strides in subsequent years, including a return to the College World Series in 2021 and a historic championship in 2024.
As the conversation around his potential shift to the MLB continues, the baseball community eagerly watches the developments surrounding Vitello and the San Francisco Giants.