Care Quality Commission Chief Executive Steps Down
Sir Julian Hartley, Chief Executive of the Care Quality Commission (CQC), has announced his resignation amid scrutiny surrounding maternity care. His departure follows a trust investigation that identified issues potentially contributing to the stillbirth of Asees, the daughter of Amarjit Kaur and Mandip Singh Matharoo, in January 2024.
Growing Concerns Over Maternity Care
The investigation revealed significant care shortcomings during Hartley’s tenure. Families affected by maternity services at the Leeds Teaching Hospitals welcomed his resignation, raising questions about his original appointment. They criticized the oversight that allowed him to lead a major regulator despite overseeing substandard maternity care.
Statements From Grieving Families
- Amarjit Kaur and Mandip Singh Matharoo expressed doubts about Hartley’s leadership and the systems that permitted his promotion.
- A whistleblower from the trust described the maternity situation under Hartley as “dire” and highlighted the necessity for change.
- A broader group of bereaved families acknowledged Hartley’s resignation but rejected his apology, claiming systemic failures remain unaddressed.
In their statements, families emphasized that it had often fallen to them to expose the shortcomings in CQC’s inspection processes and regulatory actions. They demanded accountability and the need for improved transparency.
CQC’s Response to Resignation
In response to the unfolding situation, Professor Sir Mike Richards, chair of the CQC, remarked that Hartley’s resignation could affect public trust in the organization. The CQC aims to restore confidence in its regulation of health care services.
Ongoing Investigations and Future Actions
- A rapid review of maternity services across England is currently in progress.
- An extensive inquiry, the largest ever into NHS maternity services, centered on Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, is expected to report next summer.
- The investigation of care within Leeds represents the fifth review of maternity services in a single NHS Trust since 2013.
Sir Julian Hartley expressed his regret regarding the harm some families experienced during his time at the CQC. He pledged full cooperation with ongoing inquiries to ensure families receive the answers they deserve.
