Understanding Dahbia Benkired’s Life Sentence for Lola’s Murder

Dahbia Benkired has received a life sentence for the murder of 12-year-old Lola Daviet. This ruling was announced on October 24, 2023, during the conclusion of her trial. This sentence aligns with the public prosecutor’s demand to protect society from what they deemed a highly dangerous individual.

Background of the Case

This marks a significant case in French legal history. Dahbia Benkired is the first woman in France to face this severe punishment, known as “perpétuité incompressible.” This term refers to a life sentence without the possibility of parole. Since its introduction in 1994, this sentence has been applied only five times, primarily for convicted pedophiles and once for Salah Abdeslam, a survivor of the November 2015 terrorist attacks.

Legal Context

• The life sentence was deemed necessary for public safety.
• The law allows for potential reevaluation of the sentence after 30 years under strict conditions.
• Dahbia will not be eligible to petition for a review until 27 years have passed.

Public and Judicial Reaction

This verdict reflects the high societal concerns regarding Benkired’s actions. Defense attorney Isabelle Steyer highlighted the calculated nature of Benkired’s crimes. She indicated that the methodically dangerous approach could lead to more such crimes in the future.

The victim’s mother, Delphine Daviet, expressed profound grief and relief, calling for a life-long imprisonment of Benkired, labeling her as a “monster.” This sentiment resonates with the public’s demand for justice and safety.

Judicial Perspectives

Legal experts note that the “perpétuité incompressible” is a substitute for capital punishment abolished in 1981. Initially designed for violent crimes against minors, it has expanded to include public servant murders and terrorism after the 2015 attacks.

Despite the gravity of this sentence, the judiciary may reconsider it under exceptional circumstances, such as grave illness or severe mental health issues, after the minimum period has elapsed. Nonetheless, Benkired’s current situation presents a significant challenge for her legal team, who have ten days to lodge an appeal regarding the court’s decision.