Pentagon Criticizes Netflix’s House of Dynamite for Inaccuracies
The Pentagon has expressed discontent over the portrayal of the United States’ missile defense system in Kathryn Bigelow’s film, A House of Dynamite. Released on Netflix after a brief theatrical run, the film follows the critical 18 minutes following a nuclear missile launch aimed at the U.S. Officials scramble to identify the source and respond to the imminent threat.
Concerns Raised by the Pentagon
In an internal memorandum from the Missile Defense Agency (MDA), dated October 16, significant issues were raised regarding the film’s depiction. While the MDA acknowledges that the film highlights the failures of deterrence, it asserts that the fictional representation inaccurately portrays U.S. missile defense capabilities.
- The defense secretary, played by Jared Harris, claims a 50% success rate for intercepting missiles.
- The Pentagon states real-world testing indicates current interceptors have a 100% accuracy rate over the past decade.
The MDA further critiques the film, noting that while the narrative might serve to enhance drama, it does not reflect actual capabilities. The agency emphasizes that the portrayal of interceptors missing their targets misrepresents the effectiveness of the U.S. missile defense strategy.
Controversial Claims and Realities
Another character, the deputy national security adviser played by Gabriel Basso, suggests a 61% success rate for the missile defense system. According to screenwriter Noah Oppenheim, this figure comes from data collected during controlled tests, acknowledged to be optimistic given the current resources.
- Less than 50 ground-based interceptors are available for use.
- This implies that even with perfect functioning systems, the operational capacity is limited.
The Pentagon also noted it was not consulted during the film’s production, and a representative confirmed that the film does not represent the current administration’s stance. Emphasizing the critical role of missile defense, the Pentagon highlighted its importance in ensuring national security.
Bigelow’s Approach and Film Reception
Kathryn Bigelow, known for her successful directorial achievements, stated that she chose not to seek Pentagon consultation to maintain independence. During an interview, she mentioned that, although independent, several technical advisors with Pentagon experience were present throughout the filming process.
- A House of Dynamite currently holds a 79% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes.
- It has garnered mixed reviews from audiences, especially regarding its conclusion.
In a review for Emegypt, Geoffrey Macnab praised the film as “the most entertaining movie about mass destruction since Dr. Strangelove.” As Bigelow continues to make her mark in cinematic history, A House of Dynamite presents her ongoing commitment to intelligent and thrilling drama.
A House of Dynamite is now available for streaming on Netflix. The film invites viewers to reflect on critical issues surrounding missile defense and national security while telling a suspenseful story.
