3 Unlucky 2025 Free Agents the Pirates Should Target

The Pittsburgh Pirates are exploring cost-effective strategies in the free agent market. With limited spending power, the team is considering players who have experienced down years but exhibit potential for a rebound. This approach hinges on the idea that baseball can be influenced by luck, leading to temporary struggles in even the most capable players. Here’s a look at three free agents the Pirates should target who may be undervalued after disappointing seasons in 2025.

3 Unlucky 2025 Free Agents the Pirates Should Target

Max Kepler

Max Kepler has had a challenging season after spending ten years with the Minnesota Twins. Now with the Philadelphia Phillies, he recorded a triple-slash of .216/.300/.391 over 478 plate appearances. This performance marked one of his lowest outputs to date, with a wRC+ of just 90.

Despite the setbacks, Kepler demonstrated solid underlying metrics. His walk rate rose to 10.1%, and his chase rate was an impressive 26.6%, placing him in the 56th percentile. He also maintained his power, hitting 18 home runs and achieving an isolated slugging percentage of .175. His exit velocity averaged at 90.8 MPH, showcasing his enduring power.

Expected statistics indicated Kepler was one of the most unfortunate hitters of the year. His xwOBA was a promising .340, presenting a notable gap from his actual performance, which could indicate a rebound potential. With average defensive ratings, he still could offer value for the Pirates as they build their roster.

Michael Conforto

Michael Conforto’s one-year stint with the Los Angeles Dodgers was less than ideal, resulting in a career-low .199 batting average across 486 plate appearances. His wRC+ sat at 83, with only 12 home runs and an iso of .134.

However, Conforto displayed positive hitting metrics. He boasted an 11.5% walk rate and managed a slightly below-average strikeout rate of 24.9%. His exit velocity and barrel rate were also commendable at 89.9 MPH and 9.7%, respectively. Expected statistics were even more favorable, with an xwOBA of .341 and a .246 xBA indicating significant potential for improvement in 2026.

Despite his challenges defensively, where he ranked poorly in various metrics, his hitting ability could make him an attractive target for the Pirates if they seek a potential bounce-back player.

Ty France

Ty France could be a strategic addition to the Pirates as a right-handed complement to first baseman Spencer Horwitz. After a strong All-Star season, France struggled in 2025, finishing with a .257 batting average and a wRC+ of 92.

Despite the decline in offensive output, he maintained a low strikeout rate of 16.9%, and his exit velocity climbed to a career-best 89.4 MPH. His expected batting average was considerably better than his actual performance at .268, suggesting a turnaround could be possible.

Defensively, France excelled, earning nominations as a Gold Glove finalist with +9 defensive runs saved and a leading position in outs above average (OAA). Given his prior modest contract, he could represent a valuable low-cost option for the Pirates as they seek to enhance their roster.

Conclusion

As the Pirates navigate the free agent landscape, targeting players like Max Kepler, Michael Conforto, and Ty France could help address their needs without breaking the bank. Each player presents a unique opportunity for the Pirates to improve their roster while banking on potential rebounds from disappointing seasons.