Billboard’s Top 25 Halloween Songs Ranked—Our Thoughts Differ

Billboard recently released its ranking of the top 25 Halloween songs based on performance on the Hot 100 chart. This list sparked debate among fans and critics, including staffers from All Things Considered, who voiced strong opinions on the selections.

Billboard’s Halloween Playlist

The Billboard ranking features several iconic Halloween tracks. However, many felt that the placement of certain songs was questionable.

• “Thriller” by Michael Jackson: Ranked 22, this classic is widely regarded as the ultimate Halloween anthem.
• “Monster Mash” by Bobby “Boris” Pickett: This song claimed the top spot but is not frequently played outside of Halloween.
• “This Is Halloween” from The Nightmare Before Christmas: A favorite among those who appreciate Tim Burton’s film, celebrated for its lyrical charm.
• “I Put A Spell On You” by Screamin’ Jay Hawkins: Not included in Billboard’s list, this song is beloved for its witchy allure.
• “Mind Playing Tricks On Me” by Geto Boys: This track is notable for referencing Halloween celebrations directly.
• “Freaks Come Out At Night” by Whodini: A classic song that captures the essence of Halloween nightlife.

Reactions from All Things Considered Staff

Jonas Adams, the director of All Things Considered, was particularly critical of Jackson’s “Thriller” being ranked so low. He argued that its omnipresence during Halloween makes a strong case for its top placement.

Avery Keatley, another contributor, acknowledged “Monster Mash” as a Halloween staple but admitted it might only be worth a single listen each year. Kathryn Fink shared her love for “This Is Halloween,” indicating she plays it year-round.

The staff’s discussions reveal a mix of nostalgia and passion for Halloween music. They emphasize that while Billboard’s list offers a snapshot, it may not fully capture the true essence of Halloween celebrations via song.

Conclusion

This debate underscores a larger conversation about how music reflects cultural traditions, especially those tied to specific holidays like Halloween. As playlists continue to evolve, so too will opinions about which songs deserve to be on the list.

Ultimately, Halloween songs, ranging from eerie to playful, resonate with audiences in unique ways, making every listener’s ranking a personal experience.