Is Shohei Ohtani Surpassing the Greatest Yankee of All Time?

As Major League Baseball (MLB) witnesses Shohei Ohtani’s rise, comparisons to legendary players like Babe Ruth have surfaced. Ohtani’s unique dual-threat capability has drawn admirers and analysts alike, prompting excitement about his potential to surpass greatness. But how does Ohtani stack up against Ruth, the iconic New York Yankee?

Shohei Ohtani: A Modern MLB Marvel

Shohei Ohtani, currently at 31 years old, has already made a significant impact in his eight seasons. His career Wins Above Replacement (WAR) stands at 62.2, a remarkable achievement considering he is still active. In 2024, he made headlines with a stunning season, recording 50 home runs and 50 stolen bases—an accomplishment previously unseen in modern baseball.

Babe Ruth: The Original Superstar

Babe Ruth, who played for 22 seasons, remains a benchmark in baseball history. His career WAR is unmatched at 182.6, showcasing a prolific ability to excel both as a pitcher and a hitter. While Ohtani shines in his role, Ruth’s dominance persisted over more than two decades, an achievement that casts a long shadow.

Comparison of Career Achievements

• Shohei Ohtani:
  • Age: 31
  • Seasons Played: 8
  • Career WAR: 62.2
  • Notable 2024 Season: 50 home runs and 50 stolen bases
• Babe Ruth:
  • Seasons Played: 22
  • Career WAR: 182.6
  • Best Year: 1927 with 60 home runs

The Era Factor

When comparing Ohtani and Ruth, the context of their respective eras must be considered. Ruth played during a time when the competition and training methods were vastly different. His superb physicality and skill set marked him as a generational talent. Ohtani faces modern athletes, who are often stronger and faster than those in Ruth’s time.

Ruth’s Endurance vs. Ohtani’s Dominance

Ruth’s career longevity allowed him to accumulate records and accolades. His substantial statistics come from consistent performance over decades. In contrast, Ohtani’s approach as a two-way player showcases his ability to dominate in both pitching and hitting roles, a feat that is strenuous and rare.

Potential for the Future

While Ruth’s status as a baseball legend is cemented, Ohtani’s journey is far from over. His health and continued success will play crucial roles in shaping his legacy. As he progresses through his career, baseball fans eagerly await how Ohtani’s achievements will define him.

Conclusion

As the debate continues on whether Shohei Ohtani could surpass Babe Ruth, it’s clear that both athletes have made indelible marks on the game. Ultimately, Ohtani’s journey is still unfolding, and time will tell where he stands among baseball’s greatest.