Giants Depth Chart Showdown: Tracy Battles Singletary for Top Spot

In the NFL, not every backfield is dominated by one standout player. Teams like the Titans and Giants feature a two-back system, complicating the evaluation of which player to favor. Recently, the competition between Tyrone Tracy and Devin Singletary has become increasingly prominent within the Giants’ roster.

Analyzing Giants’ Running Back Situation

Through the first two games of the current season, both Tracy and Singletary have been the primary running backs. Their performance offers insight into their viability as fantasy football options.

Snap Counts and Carry Distribution

• Week 9:
  • Singletary: 56% of snaps, 8 carries
  • Tracy: 44% of snaps, 5 carries
• Week 10:
  • Singletary: 33% of snaps, 8 carries
  • Tracy: 67% of snaps, 14 carries

The shift in snap counts indicates a growing trust in Tracy as the preferred option. Despite Singletary’s higher snap percentage in the first game, Tracy’s rise in Week 10 challenges that narrative.

Efficiency Metrics

Efficiency is key when evaluating their performances. Over the past two weeks:

• Singletary averaged 4.0 yards per carry.
• Tracy showcased greater effectiveness with 4.7 yards per carry.

Coaching Changes Impacting Running Back Dynamics

The recent firing of head coach Brian Daboll brings uncertainty to the Giants’ offensive strategy. Mike Kafka, previously the offensive coordinator, has stepped in as the interim head coach. His approach may influence the running back’s distribution of carries moving forward.

As the Giants aim to remain competitive, Kafka will likely prioritize efficient players, which leans toward Tracy at this stage. Expectations are that Tracy will take on a larger share of the carries, potentially ranging from 60% to 75% of team snaps weekly.

Projected Performance

The Giants currently rank 11th in rushing yards per game, averaging 123.0 yards. However, this number may adjust downward as the season progresses. If Tracy maintains his position as the lead back, he could realistically achieve:

• 40–50% of team rushing yards.
• 50–75 rushing yards per game.
• 2–4 receptions per game, adding moderate value in PPR formats.

Singletary, on the other hand, is projected for 20-40 rushing yards per game and is expected to receive fewer opportunities in the passing game.

Conclusion

In summary, Tyrone Tracy appears to be emerging as the primary running back for the Giants, especially after the recent coaching changes. Meanwhile, Devin Singletary may remain a suitable backup or stash, although his role may be diminished moving forward. As the team adapts to these changes, monitoring their performance in upcoming games will be essential for fantasy football players.