Is Christmas Music Playing Too Soon? Likely
On November 1, Mariah Carey announced the start of the Christmas music season, particularly highlighting her classic hit, “All I Want for Christmas Is You.” This proclamation has sparked an ongoing conversation about the appropriate time to begin playing Christmas music.
Mariah Carey’s Annual Announcement
Carey, often regarded as the unofficial ambassador of Christmas, declared that the holiday festivities had officially begun. Her announcement serves as a tradition that divides opinions on when festive music should commence.
Controversy Over Timing
The staff of All Things Considered shared their mixed feelings regarding the early start to the Christmas music season. Jonas Adams, the director, expressed that it feels premature, stating he had just removed his Halloween decorations.
Producer Vincent Acovino echoed these sentiments, arguing for a more condensed celebration period. He suggested that the Christmas spirit should be celebrated for only a week rather than extending it over two months.
Varying Opinions on Listening to Christmas Music
- Elena Burnett: A self-proclaimed Christmas music fan, Burnett prefers to wait until after Thanksgiving to immerse herself in holiday tunes. She worries that starting too early may lead to burnout by the actual holiday.
- Erika Ryan: Ryan takes a more extreme stance. Having worked in retail, she favors a complete ban on Christmas music in public spaces, associating it with her challenging experiences.
- Scott Detrow: Detrow agrees with Adams, suggesting that music should only start the day after Thanksgiving, marking the true beginning of the holiday season.
- Juana Summers: Summers shared her unenthusiastic view, indicating she only enjoys the music on Christmas Day itself.
In Conclusion
The debate on whether Christmas music is played too soon continues to thrive. With differing views among the All Things Considered staff, it’s clear that this topic evokes strong feelings. Regardless of opinions, they collectively wish everyone a merry Christmas, even as the holiday approaches slowly.
