Andrew Coster’s Decline as Leader of Progressive Policing
Former police commissioner Andrew Coster, once hailed as a leader in progressive policing, now faces significant challenges following a critical report. A recent investigation by the Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA) exposed serious misconduct within police leadership, tarnishing Coster’s legacy and reputation.
Decline of Andrew Coster’s Leadership
Currently, Coster is on leave from his role as chief executive of the government’s Social Investment Agency. The IPCA found that police executives, including Coster, failed to address longstanding complaints from a young woman regarding former deputy commissioner Jevon McSkimming. Allegations date back to 2018, but action was only taken in mid-2024 after police charged the woman.
Key Findings of the IPCA Report
- Leadership Failures: The report describes a failure of leadership within the police force.
- Allegation Dismissal: Both Coster and McSkimming did not disclose serious allegations during McSkimming’s appointment process in early 2023.
- Improper Investigation: The IPCA criticized the handling of the investigation, stating it was poorly conducted and delayed.
As the inquiry progressed, Coster expressed concerns that the IPCA’s actions could harm McSkimming’s future career. Interestingly, he prioritized “natural justice” for McSkimming, which further complicated the investigation.
Coster’s Background and Initial Rise
Andrew Coster was appointed police commissioner in March 2020 at the age of 44, making him the youngest in the role. His appointment was initially praised by then-Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern, who highlighted his integrity and leadership skills.
Political Reactions and Changes
However, tensions arose between Coster and the National Party, particularly during their time in opposition. Party members accused him of being lenient toward gang activities. After the National Party won the 2023 election, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon took a softer stance on Coster, allowing him to continue his term until his early resignation to lead the Social Investment Agency.
In his new position, support for Coster was reaffirmed by Police Minister Mark Mitchell, who acknowledged his integrity and contributions. Despite a successful period in leadership, Coster’s recent challenges highlight the complexities of policing and accountability.
