Legal Battle Intensifies Over Release Plans for Lost Earth Black Sabbath Demos as Sharon Osbourne Issues Threats

A legal dispute has escalated over unreleased recordings from the early band Earth, which eventually became Black Sabbath. The conflict involves all four original Black Sabbath members: Ozzy Osbourne, Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler, and Bill Ward. Jim Simpson, who managed Earth, plans to release an album titled “Earth: The Legendary Lost Tapes.” However, he faces threats of legal action from Sharon Osbourne, Ozzy’s wife and Black Sabbath’s manager.

Background on Earth and Black Sabbath

Earth was an early name for the band that ultimately transformed into Black Sabbath, a legendary heavy metal group. The band’s classic lineup achieved worldwide fame shortly after their debut album in 1970.

The Release Plan

Simpson aims to share previously unreleased recordings from Earth, claiming he paid for the studio sessions in 1969. He contends that these recordings belong to him due to a contract he had with the band. Sharon Osbourne, however, disputes this claim, citing the unclear ownership of the recordings and questioning Simpson’s financial capability to pay for the studio time.

• Album Title: Earth: The Legendary Lost Tapes
• Release Delays: Currently hindered by legal threats from Sharon Osbourne
• Claimed Studio Payment: £500 for the recordings

Sharon Osbourne’s Statements

During a recent episode of ‘The Osbourne Podcast,’ Sharon criticized Simpson, stating he failed to discuss a partnership prior to announcing his release plans. She mentioned that Simpson’s actions could harm the original members of Black Sabbath, arguing that he is attempting to profit off their legacy without proper compensation to them.

Simpson’s Response

In response to Sharon’s criticisms, Simpson refuted her comments as “inaccurate and unfair.” He emphasized his financial involvement in producing the recordings and the importance of these tracks in rock music history. His press release reveals his desire for royalties to be shared among all band members, contrary to Sharon’s claims. Furthermore, he suggested that a charity would receive any unclaimed royalties if Black Sabbath declined their earnings.

Legal and Financial Implications

Sharon indicated the band’s initial success did not lead to fair compensation for them, while Simpson claims the opposite was true during his management. He asserts that he wants to ensure proper financial distribution if the album is released. The album consists of various tracks that showcase Earth’s evolution toward the heavy metal sound.

• Tracks Included:
  • Blue Suede Shoes
  • Evenin’
  • Wee Wee Baby
  • Song For Jim (two versions)
  • Untitled track
  • Free Man
  • Wicked World
  • Warning

Potential Future Developments

The ongoing tension between Simpson and Sharon Osbourne reflects a broader conversation about artist rights and legacy. As the legal battle continues, both parties have expressed willingness to negotiate a resolution that honors the contributions of all involved.

Simpson’s aim to release “Earth: The Legendary Lost Tapes” could provide a significant look into the roots of a band that shaped rock music. As of now, the situation remains fluid, with the potential for legal outcomes that could redefine the rights to these historical recordings.