Sharon Osbourne Threatens as Legal Clash Over Lost Earth Black Sabbath Demos Heats Up
A legal conflict has heightened over previously unreleased recordings from the band Earth, the predecessor to Black Sabbath. This dispute involves all four founding members of Black Sabbath: Ozzy Osbourne, Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler, and Bill Ward. Jim Simpson, the band’s former manager, intends to release an album titled “Earth: The Legendary Lost Tapes.” However, Sharon Osbourne, wife of Ozzy Osbourne and current Black Sabbath manager, threatens legal action against him.
Background of Earth and Black Sabbath
Earth served as the initial name for what would eventually become the iconic heavy metal band, Black Sabbath. The group achieved worldwide fame following the release of their debut album in 1970. Their evolution from Earth to Black Sabbath marked a significant chapter in rock music history.
Album Release Plans
Jim Simpson claims he financed the studio sessions for these recordings in 1969. He believes the unreleased demos belong to him based on an existing contract. However, Sharon Osbourne disputes this claim, raising concerns about the ownership and Simpson’s ability to fund the recordings.
Details of the Legal Dispute
- Album Title: Earth: The Legendary Lost Tapes
- Claimed Studio Payment: £500
- Release Delays: Currently hindered by legal threats from Sharon Osbourne
Sharon Osbourne’s Statements
In a recent episode of ‘The Osbourne Podcast,’ Sharon criticized Simpson for failing to discuss a partnership before making public his release plans. She argued that his actions could jeopardize the legacy of Black Sabbath, accusing him of seeking profit at the expense of the original band members.
Jim Simpson’s Response
Simpson countered Sharon’s remarks, labeling them as “inaccurate and unfair.” He asserted his significant financial investment in the recordings and stated that the unreleased tracks hold great importance in rock music history. Simpson also expressed his desire for any potential royalties to be distributed fairly among the band members.
Legal and Financial Implications
Sharon Osbourne pointed out that the band’s early success did not lead to fair financial returns, while Simpson claimed the opposite during his management. He emphasizes ensuring proper financial distribution should the album reach the market.
Track Listing for Earth: The Legendary Lost Tapes
- Blue Suede Shoes
- Evenin’
- Wee Wee Baby
- Song For Jim (two versions)
- Untitled track
- Free Man
- Wicked World
- Warning
Future Developments
The ongoing tension between Jim Simpson and Sharon Osbourne highlights a vital discussion about artist rights and legacies in the music industry. Both parties have shown interest in negotiating a resolution that honors everyone involved. The release of “Earth: The Legendary Lost Tapes” could provide valuable insight into the origins of a band that greatly influenced rock music. The situation remains fluid, with potential legal outcomes that may affect the ownership of these historic recordings.
