French military chief faces backlash over statement on being ‘prepared to lose children’

France’s Chief of Defence Staff, General Fabien Mandon, has sparked significant controversy following his remarks about readiness to “lose children” amid the ongoing conflict with Russia. During a speech to local mayors, Mandon emphasized the necessity for the country to adopt a mindset capable of enduring sacrifices for national security.

General Mandon’s Controversial Statements

In his address this past Tuesday, Mandon pointed out that although France possesses strong economic and demographic resources, it lacks the societal spirit required to confront the Russian threat robustly. He stated, “We have all the knowledge, all the economic and demographic strength to deter the Moscow regime.” However, he cautioned that failure to accept the potential costs could place France at risk.

Context of the Ukraine Conflict

The comments come in the wake of the ongoing war between Russia and Ukraine, which began in February 2022. While European nations, including France, have supported Ukraine with military supplies, they maintain that they are not directly involved in the conflict.

Political Reactions

• President Emmanuel Macron: He and other officials have urged the public to prepare for possible sacrifices, arguing that failure to do so might embolden Russia.
• Jean-Luc Mélenchon: The left-wing leader expressed strong disagreement with Mandon, questioning the legitimacy of his call for preparation for war.
• Louis Aliot: The deputy leader of the National Rally asserted that sacrifices for war must be justified and questioned the public readiness to fight for Ukraine.
• Fabien Roussel: The Communist Party leader criticized Mandon’s rhetoric, emphasizing that past sacrifices should not be trivialized.
• Christian Estrosi: The mayor of Nice criticized Mandon’s comments, suggesting that they portray weakness rather than strength.

Broader Implications for EU Defence

In light of increased tensions, the European Commission has projected that EU defense spending will reach approximately €392 billion this year, nearly double the figure from four years prior. Over the next decade, total defense expenditure is expected to surpass €3.4 trillion, reflecting growing concerns over security in the region.

As discussions about national security and military readiness continue in France, General Mandon’s remarks have ignited a critical conversation about the sacrifices and spirit required for the defense of the nation.