Giants Urged to Retain GM Joe Schoen, Hire Experienced Coach
In the wake of the New York Giants’ recent struggles, franchise owners John Mara and Steve Tisch have made significant decisions affecting the team’s future. Following their eighth loss this season and a troubling record of 22 losses in 27 games, the Giants have fired head coach Brian Daboll. This decision was anticipated, as Daboll’s tenure was not closely tied to general manager Joe Schoen, who might remain in his role through 2026.
Retain GM Joe Schoen for Stability
Despite the Giants’ turbulent past few seasons, keeping Schoen as GM could provide necessary stability. Since his arrival in 2022, Schoen has navigated the franchise through challenging times, leading to a playoff appearance in his first year with a 9-7-1 record. Yet, his overall record now stands at 20-40-1 with multiple coaching changes.
- 2021: Fired GM Dave Gettleman (19-46 record)
- 2022: Schoen hired as GM
- 2023: Schoen remains amid coaching changes
The Search for an Experienced Coach
The pursuit of a qualified head coach is now paramount. While the Giants have not publicly committed to Schoen beyond 2026, internal sources indicate he will lead the coaching search. An experienced coach is a critical requirement, especially considering the franchise’s frequent turnover—four GMs and six head coaches in ten years have hindered progress.
Current options include:
- Mike McCarthy: Former Super Bowl champion
- Kevin Stefanski: Possible availability from the Browns
- Mike Tomlin: Might also be an option from the Steelers
Challenges Ahead for the Giants
Both Mara and Tisch are understandably frustrated by a third consecutive season of double-digit losses. The Giants tied an NFL record this season by allowing five blown 10-point leads, indicating crucial failures in management and coaching. These factors ultimately led to Daboll’s dismissal.
With players like quarterback Daniel Jones and left tackle Andrew Thomas on the roster, the potential for a quick turnaround exists. However, the Giants can’t afford to repeat past mistakes. The ideal candidate must possess previous coaching experience to avoid a similar fate as Daboll, Joe Judge, and Ben McAdoo.
Looking Toward the Future
While the current roster is rife with promise, Schoen faces scrutiny regarding his draft selections, including notable misses. Nevertheless, his ability to manage the salary cap and maintain a competitive roster has garnered positive feedback from team insiders.
Success for Schoen and the new head coach will depend on their ability to develop the raw talent on the team and craft a strong culture moving forward. Patience is now a critical virtue, as rushing to change everything might lead the franchise back to square one.
In summary, as the Giants weigh their next steps, retaining GM Joe Schoen and seeking out an experienced head coach could prove vital in reversing the team’s fortunes and restoring its former glory.
