HSE Issues Apology to Couple Misguided with Fatal Foetal Abnormality Diagnosis

The Health Service Executive (HSE) has issued a formal apology to a couple after a severe misdiagnosis led to a tragic termination of their pregnancy. Bernard Gloster, the HSE chief executive, expressed regret over the mishap that resulted in the couple believing their healthy baby had a fatal foetal abnormality.

Timeline of Events

Rebecca Price and Pat Kiely, residents of Phibsborough, Dublin, were informed in early 2019 that their unborn child had a serious condition known as Trisomy 18, which is linked to Edwards Syndrome. This was after a series of tests, including a regular ultrasound and a Harmony test that indicated potential abnormalities.

• 2018: The couple learned they were expecting their first child on Christmas Eve.
• February 2019: A routine 12-week ultrasound scan indicated normal fetal development.
• March 2019: Following a series of invasive tests, the couple was advised that their baby would not survive.
• June 2021: They settled their High Court action after the hospital and two associated clinics admitted liability.

Consequences of the Misdiagnosis

After the misdiagnosis, Ms. Price was advised by her consultant that the pregnancy was non-viable and opted for a termination, believing it was necessary due to the perceived fatal foetal abnormality. However, further tests later confirmed that the baby did not have Trisomy 18.

HSE’s Response

In a statement released on Saturday, Gloster acknowledged the profound loss experienced by Price and Kiely after the care provided at Holles Street Hospital. He stated an independent external review would be initiated to gain a comprehensive understanding of the situation.

Gloster emphasized the importance of accountability, stating, “Nobody can undo the harm suffered, but it’s crucial that this is documented and we extend an unequivocal apology on behalf of the health service.”

Impact and Future Actions

The couple has expressed their hope that their tragic experience could lead to improvements in medical care. In 2021, Kiely remarked that the experience altered their lives significantly. Price mentioned that if their baby Christopher’s legacy could prevent future medical failures, that would be a positive outcome.

This case serves as a reminder of the necessity for careful diagnosis and communication in maternal healthcare and highlights the need for continued vigilance within the health service to avoid similar tragedies in the future.