Mark Rowley Risks Losing Opportunity to Transform the Met Police

Sir Mark Rowley, the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, faces a critical crossroads. With just under two years remaining in his five-year term, there is concern that his tenure may be perceived as an opportunity wasted. Appointed in late 2022, Rowley’s leadership emerged amid numerous challenges that the Met was grappling with.

Challenges Facing the Met Police Under Rowley

Despite reported decreases in knife crime this year, the Metropolitan Police’s performance remains concerning. Compared to other regions, London experiences substantially higher rates of knife crime:

• 17.8% higher than the West Midlands
• 36.8% higher than Greater Manchester
• 44.6% higher than South Yorkshire
• 46.9% higher than West Yorkshire

Furthermore, analysis shows that the Met resolves only a small percentage of various crime types:

• 1 in 13 shoplifting cases
• 1 in 20 robberies and burglaries
• 1 in 76 bicycle thefts
• 1 in 179 theft from the person (e.g., pickpocketing)

Internal Politics and Accountability Issues

Rowley’s efforts have been hampered by internal and external pressures. Much time appears to be dedicated to addressing the interests of various stakeholder groups, some of which seem less interested in effective policing than advancing their agendas. This misalignment has led to ineffective responses to the pressing crime issues.

Systemic flaws in recruitment, training, and vetting have also plagued the force. Many responsible for these areas have yet to be held accountable for their shortcomings. In many cases, underperforming local commanders are simply reassigned, often escaping the consequences of their failures.

Progress Made and Challenges Ahead

Despite these challenges, Rowley has made commendable strides. Efforts have been made to dismiss officers who do not meet conduct standards. Technological advancements such as live facial recognition, data analytics for identifying predators, and drone technology are being increasingly utilized under his leadership.

The decline in homicide rates and the high solvability rate of murders in London, at 95%, suggest that some progress has been made. However, Rowley has faced scrutiny regarding his political leadership, particularly with the appointment of Kaya Comer-Schwartz as deputy mayor for policing and crime. Critics argue that her skepticism towards effective crime-fighting tools may hinder Rowley’s objectives.

The Path Forward for the Metropolitan Police

The Home Secretary has a crucial role in reassessing the oversight of the Metropolitan Police. Temporarily removing the Mayor of London’s oversight powers may enhance scrutiny and allow for more effective governance. Additionally, the Met’s national counter-terrorism responsibilities could benefit from being separated into a distinct entity led by a chief constable, allowing the Met to concentrate on local crime issues.

For Rowley to leave a lasting legacy, he must prioritize accountability among senior leadership and drive measurable crime-fighting success. Demonstrating decisive leadership and commitment to tackling crime effectively will be essential for the Metropolitan Police’s transformation into a powerful crime-fighting force.