Paul Scholes Criticizes Ruben Amorim: Man Utd Legend Questions His Fit for the Club

Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has publicly critiqued the current manager, Ruben Amorim, claiming he is not the right fit for the club. Scholes’ remarks follow a recent victory, where United secured a resounding 4-1 win against Wolves, placing them sixth in the Premier League standings.

Paul Scholes Questions Ruben Amorim’s Fit at Manchester United

In a recent episode of his podcast, “The Good, the Bad and the Football,” Scholes expressed his strong disapproval of Amorim’s managerial style. Despite some improvement in results, Scholes believes the Portuguese manager fails to understand the essence of Manchester United.

Concerns Over Playing Style

Scholes criticized Amorim for a lack of entertainment and risk in the team’s play. He stated, “Man United is about risk and entertainment, more than anything. Having fans on the edge of their seat.” This sentiment highlights a perceived disconnect between Amorim’s tactics and the club’s traditional playing philosophy.

• Scholes emphasizes the need for wingers who can beat defenders.
• He believes shots on goal and skillful play are lacking.
• Scholes argues for a more aggressive approach, stating, “When you score one, you score two.”

Managerial Philosophy and Tactical Choices

Dissatisfaction stems from Amorim’s strategy of fielding three defenders, which Scholes asserts is not aligned with Manchester United’s historical tactics. He stated, “Man United never do that. They just can’t; it’s been proven over years.” Scholes recalls a time under Sir Alex Ferguson when the team consistently played a more dynamic formation.

Despite the changes, Amorim has steered Manchester United away from their previous struggles. They are currently one point away from the top four, a promising position compared to their disastrous 2024/25 campaign.

Future Prospects

While Amorim appears to retain the confidence of the club’s hierarchy and is not in immediate danger of losing his position, Scholes’ criticism reflects broader concerns among fans. The club has faced difficulties since Ferguson’s retirement, compounded by the Glazers’ ownership.

Investment from INEOS in February 2024 has initiated a new vision for United, but the challenges remain significant. Scholes’ insights underscore the complexities of revitalizing a storied club like Manchester United under a new managerial regime.