Keir Starmer grilled by senior MPs on his prime ministerial record

During a recent parliamentary session, Keir Starmer faced intense scrutiny from senior MPs regarding his record as Prime Minister. The session highlighted significant political tensions and concerns over various policies.

Key Concerns Raised by MPs

Cat Smith, a member of Starmer’s own party and representing a rural Lancashire constituency, criticized the impending inheritance tax set to affect family farms from next April. She argued that this decision has misled Labour voters and significantly threatened the livelihood of farmers. Smith stated that some farmers are making drastic decisions about their future in response to this policy.

In her remarks, Smith described Starmer’s past policy adjustments as commendable, specifically referencing changes in winter fuel and welfare. She urged him to reconsider the inheritance tax policy, emphasizing the impact it would have on families.

Responses from Keir Starmer

Starmer appeared uncomfortable with the criticism from Smith and additional questions from Alistair Carmichael of the Liberal Democrats. However, he defended the inheritance tax decision, signaling no intention to reverse it.

The Prime Minister also responded to inquiries from Conservative MP Simon Hoare about the recent resident doctors’ strike. Starmer expressed that he felt “gutted” regarding the strike, assigning it a severity level of 10 out of 10. He suggested that the British Medical Association (BMA) was losing support from other health professionals and the public due to this situation.

Challenges in Government Preparation

Dame Meg Hillier, the committee chair, raised concerns about preparedness within the government. In response, Starmer expressed his frustration with encountering numerous obstacles, including excessive consultations and regulations that impede his plans for change.

His sentiments reflect the challenges facing not only his government but also resonate with many disillusioned voters, as indicated by his party’s rankings in the polls.

Summary of Criticisms

• Smith criticized the inheritance tax’s impact on family farms.
• Starmer defended the policy amidst rising discontent.
• Concern over support loss from the BMA during the doctors’ strike.
• Expression of frustration over government readiness and bureaucratic hurdles.

The session concluded with Starmer’s acknowledgment of the significant challenges ahead, both in governance and public perception.