Top Solutions to End the Buffalo Sabres’ Three-Goalie Dilemma

Colten Ellis resumed skating with the Buffalo Sabres as he moves through the NHL’s concussion protocol. This development poses challenges for the Sabres, who currently have three goalies on their active roster. Jarmo Kekalainen, who recently took over as the general manager, acknowledged the need for a quick resolution to this complex situation.

Buffalo Sabres’ Goalie Conundrum

As of now, the Sabres’ three goaltenders have posted a combined save percentage of .897 over 32 games, placing them 17th in the league. Head coach Lindy Ruff has tried various strategies, but the inconsistency among the netminders persists.

Kekalainen faces pressure to address this three-goalie dilemma. It remains unclear which goalie will be removed from the roster. Here are some potential solutions to this issue:

1. Trade Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen

Moving Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen could solve the current goalie situation while providing salary-cap flexibility. He is under contract until the 2028-29 season with a salary of $4.75 million. Trading Luukkonen would also open a roster spot for exciting prospect Devon Levi next season.

2. Waive Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen

If a trade is not possible, waiving Luukkonen might be the next best option. Despite a solid .910 save percentage last season, his overall performance has declined. His performance statistics include save percentages of .891, .887, and .884 in prior seasons.

3. Trade Alex Lyon

There is likely interest in Alex Lyon from other teams. The 33-year-old has been the Sabres’ most reliable goalie this season, sporting a .905 save percentage when given regular starts. However, trading him could align better with the Sabres’ long-term plans.

4. Trade Colten Ellis

Colten Ellis has shown potential, and there were previous inquiries from the St. Louis Blues about reacquiring him. The Blues currently struggle with goaltending, ranking near the bottom with an .882 team save percentage. Exploring a trade could yield valuable assets for the Sabres.

5. Waive Colten Ellis

While not ideal, waiving Ellis could be a simpler way to resolve the goaltending issue. However, this might lead to losing a promising young goalie for nothing, especially if St. Louis claims him.

6. Waive Alex Lyon

Waiving Lyon would weaken the Sabres’ chances this season, leaving the team with UPL and Ellis to manage the net. This would not resolve long-term dilemmas and could jeopardize the Sabres’ current playoff aspirations.

As Kekalainen weighs these options, the Buffalo Sabres must act swiftly to ensure they optimize their roster for potential playoff contention.